Title: The Unforgotten Slave: Betsey Jackson’s Story
As we walk through the grand halls of the Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church, we can’t help but admire its splendor and grandeur. But, there’s a haunting truth hidden behind these walls that we can’t ignore.
It’s a tale of the past, a story that has been buried beneath the foundation of the church. A story of a founding member of the church, Betsey Jackson, an enslaved woman, who was owned and abused by the church’s first pastor.
Betsey Jackson was one of the 26 original members who joined the Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church in 1808, hoping to find solace and sanctity in its walls. Built on principles of love and compassion, the church would have been a place of refuge for Betsey, but it became her dungeon.
She was bought and sold like a mere commodity, stripped of all her dignity and reduced to the status of a slave. Her screams for freedom were silenced, and her pleas for justice fell on deaf ears.
Betsey was forced into a life of servitude under the first pastor of the church, who used her as a pawn in his games of power and control. She was subjected to untold horrors and humiliations without any recourse.
Even after years of slavery, when the shackles of bondage were finally lifted, the church forgot Betsey’s struggles and overlooked her contributions. Her name was erased from history, and her story was buried deep beneath the shadows.
It’s only in recent times that the church has come to terms with its past and recognized its ties to slavery. Through the naming of its boardroom after Betsey, the church has taken small steps towards redemption.
But, as we walk through the halls of the Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church, we can’t forget Betsey’s story. Her struggles remind us that the sins of our past can’t be ignored, and that every voice deserves to be heard.
Betsey, the unforgotten slave, will forever remain a symbol of courage and resilience in the face of adversity. Her story reminds us that we can’t erase our past, but we can acknowledge it, learn from it, and strive to create a better future.

Betsey Jackson, a founding member of Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church, was enslaved by its first pastor. Upon discovering its ties to slavery, the Church named its boardroom after Jackson as a way to acknowledge and reconcile its history.